David Torrance in his book “Battle for Britain” argues for a federal UK. If this had been taken forward at the time of the original referendum in 1979 it might have been an ideal solution. Unfortunately we are now in a situation where there is no going back. The choice is stark. Either vote Yes for the ability to determine our own future or vote No for a very uncertain outcome attached to an ever more neocon Westminster Parliament with a good chance of of devolved powers being reduced. Remember Cameron said the NHS was safe in his hands. Yes safely being handed over to privatisation.